Best Pillow for Back and Side Sleepers: How to Choose When You Do Both

    If you sleep on both your back and your side, the best pillow is the one whose height fits the position you fall asleep in, and then works acceptably in the other. No single stock height fits every body in both positions, so measurement matters more than fill or brand.

    Key takeaways

    • A back sleeper and a side sleeper need different pillow heights, because the gap between head and mattress is different in each position. Combination sleepers need a considered compromise.
    • Choose for the position you fall asleep in. Pillowise uses that position, plus three body measurements and mattress firmness, to pick one of 7 sizes.
    • A fitted pillow is an adjunct to care, not a treatment. If you wake with persistent pain, numbness or headaches, see your own provider.

    Why is it hard to find one pillow for back and side sleeping?

    On your back, the head rests close to the mattress. The pillow only needs to support the curve of the neck and keep the head from tipping forward or back. On your side, the shoulder becomes the widest point between your head and the mattress. The pillow has to fill that gap so the neck stays roughly level.

    That means the same pillow can feel right in one position and wrong in the other. A pillow tall enough for your side can push your chin toward your chest when you roll onto your back. A pillow low enough for your back can leave your head tilting toward the mattress when you roll onto your side.

    We cover each position in more detail on our pages for back sleepers and side sleepers. This guide is about the overlap between them.

    Which position should I choose the pillow for?

    Choose for the position you fall asleep in. This is also how a Pillowise fitting defines sleeping position. It is the position you start the night in, not the one you wake up in. If you truly cannot tell, the fitting defaults to side.

    There is a practical reason for this. You are most likely to lie still in your starting position, and settling comfortably is what lets you fall asleep. During the night most people shift, and we describe how that works in How We Move During Sleep.

    What does the pillow need to do in each position?

    PositionThe gap to fillTypical problem with the wrong height
    BackSmall gap behind the head; the neck needs support under its curveToo high: chin pushed toward the chest. Too low: head tipped back.
    SideLarger gap, set mainly by shoulder widthToo high: neck bent away from the mattress. Too low: neck bent toward it.

    For a closer look at how shoulder width drives side-sleeping height, see Side Sleeping, Shoulders, and Pillow Height. In a pilot EMG study of 15 adults, a pillow height matched to shoulder width produced the lowest neck and shoulder muscle activity during side sleeping (Jiao et al., 2025).

    What does the research not show?

    That study was small and the participants were healthy adults. It looked at side sleeping, not at people who switch between positions, and it does not show that a matched pillow treats neck or shoulder pain. We read it as support for the idea that height should be matched to the body, not as proof of a clinical effect.

    How do I tell if my current pillow suits both positions?

    Lie in your starting position for a few minutes, then roll into the other. Ask a second person to look at you from the side, or take a photo. Check these points:

    1. Back position. Your face should point roughly at the ceiling, not at your feet. Your neck should feel supported, not pushed forward.
    2. Side position. Your nose should line up roughly with the center of your chest, not tilted up or down.
    3. Morning check. Note whether you wake with a stiff neck or an arm that has gone numb. Both can be signs of a height mismatch, though they have other causes too.

    Our guide How to Tell if Your Pillow Is the Wrong Height goes through the signs in more detail, and What Is the Right Pillow Height? explains the basics.

    Does my mattress change the answer?

    Yes. On a softer mattress, the shoulder and body sink deeper, so the gap to fill is smaller, especially on the side. On a firm mattress, they sink less. Body weight matters for the same reason: a heavier person sinks deeper and may need a lower pillow. Weight is not a direct input in the Pillowise fitting, which is why a provider checks how you lie on the pillow and adjusts if needed. If you do not know your mattress firmness, a fitting uses medium. That applies to memory foam mattresses and hotel beds too. See How to Choose a Pillow by Sleep Position for more.

    How does Pillowise approach combination sleepers?

    A Pillowise fitting combines five factors: three measurements and two preferences. The measurements are shoulder width, neck circumference and neck height. The preferences are your sleeping position (back, side or stomach) and your mattress firmness (soft, medium or firm). The Pillowise algorithm then picks one of 7 sizes. Two people with very different bodies can end up with the same size, because all five factors are combined.

    The system indicates the right size for about 95% of people. For a combination sleeper, the provider measures your body, takes your starting position as the input, and checks how you lie on the pillow in both positions. A fitted pillow cannot change its height during the night. What it does is start from a height chosen for your body, not a stock average.

    The pillow itself has a core of 100% premium Dutch memory foam, non-toxic and latex-free. The cover is 40% Tencel and 60% polyester, removable and machine washable at 104°F (40°C). You can read more on the Pillowise pillow page.

    If the size does not suit you, give the pillow 7 to 10 days to adjust. After that you can exchange it for another size, or return it for a refund, within 30 days of purchase. Return shipping is paid by the customer, and shipping charges are not refunded. If you use an FSA or HSA, ask your plan administrator whether the purchase qualifies.

    When will a pillow not be enough?

    A pillow does not fix a neck or shoulder condition. Persistent pain, numbness or tingling, headaches that keep returning, or pain after an injury all need an assessment by your own chiropractor, physical therapist or doctor. A fitted pillow works alongside that care. It is one part of the picture, the part you bring home every night.

    Find a provider near you

    Pillowise is sold only through licensed chiropractors, physical therapists and massage therapists. There is no retail store and no direct webshop. A provider takes your measurements and picks your size. The measurement is free at every reseller. You can also try the manual size calculator first to see how the process works.

    Find a Pillowise provider near you for a free measurement.

    Are you a chiropractor, PT or LMT? You can register as a Pillowise reseller.

    Thijs van der Hilst, physiotherapist
    Co-founder of Pillowise