Insomnia: Is It a Sleep Disorder, and Can a Pillow Help?

    Yes, insomnia is a sleep disorder. The DSM-5-TR lists it as insomnia disorder under sleep-wake disorders (American Psychiatric Association, 2022). A fitted pillow does not treat insomnia.

    Key takeaways

    • Insomnia is a recognized sleep disorder. It often occurs alongside stress, low mood, anxiety or pain, but it is not a personal failing.
    • Persistent insomnia needs a physician or sleep specialist. First-line care is usually cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) (Qaseem et al., American College of Physicians, 2016).
    • A fitted pillow supports a neutral neck position. That can remove one physical reason for discomfort in bed, but it is not a treatment for insomnia.

    Is insomnia a sleep disorder or a mental illness?

    It is both a sleep disorder and a diagnosis in a mental health manual, and the two descriptions do not conflict. The DSM-5-TR places it with the sleep-wake disorders. It can occur on its own or together with depression, anxiety, pain or another medical condition. For how lost sleep and mood affect each other, see Sleep Loss and Mood: What Research Shows.

    What do doctors recommend for insomnia?

    The American College of Physicians recommends CBT-I as the first treatment for chronic insomnia (Qaseem et al., 2016). See your own physician if poor sleep continues and affects your days. Habits matter too, and we cover two of them separately: caffeine and alcohol. For general routines, read What Is Sleep Hygiene, and Does Your Pillow Count?

    Can a pillow help with insomnia?

    A pillow does not cause or cure insomnia. A pillow that is too high or too low can tilt the neck for hours, and neck discomfort can interrupt sleep. A pillow that fits can take that one factor out of the picture. It does nothing for the thoughts, worry or body clock behind most insomnia.

    Pain and sleep affect each other, and the research is mostly about association, not cause. Our overview is in Does Poor Sleep Make Neck Pain Worse? If you wake with a sore neck, start with Waking Up With Neck Pain: Common Causes and What to Check First.

    How does Pillowise approach pillow fit?

    A pillow should fit the body, like a shoe size. A provider takes three measurements: shoulder width, neck circumference and neck height. We add your sleeping position (side, back or stomach) and mattress firmness. The Pillowise algorithm then picks one of 7 sizes. The system indicates the right size for about 95% of people. Weight is not part of the calculation, so the provider checks your position on the pillow and adjusts if needed.

    Give the pillow 7 to 10 days to adjust. Within 30 days of purchase you can exchange it for another size or return it for a refund. Return shipping is paid by the customer.

    Find a provider near you

    Pillowise is sold only through licensed chiropractors, physical therapists and massage therapists. The measurement is free at every provider. If your sleep problem lasts, talk to your physician first and treat the pillow as a comfort question only.

    Find a Pillowise provider near you for a free measurement

    Are you a chiropractor, PT or LMT? See how to become a Pillowise reseller.

    Thijs van der Hilst, physiotherapist
    Co-founder of Pillowise