Does Mattress Firmness Affect Pillow Height?

    Yes. Mattress firmness changes how far your shoulder and head sink, which changes the gap your pillow has to fill. In general, a softer mattress calls for a lower pillow and a firmer mattress for a higher one, but body size and sleeping position matter just as much.

    Key takeaways

    • On a soft mattress the shoulder sinks in and the gap shrinks, so side sleepers often need less pillow height. A firm mattress leaves a bigger gap.
    • Firmness is one of five factors in a Pillowise fitting, alongside shoulder width, neck circumference, neck height and sleeping position.
    • A new mattress or a mattress topper can change the fit, so a pillow that worked before may stop working.

    Why does the mattress change the pillow height I need?

    A pillow fills the space between your head and the mattress. For a side sleeper, the shoulder is the widest point in that space. On a firm mattress the shoulder barely sinks, so the gap stays large and needs more height. On a soft or memory foam mattress the shoulder sinks in, the gap gets smaller, and the same pillow can end up too high. Back sleepers are usually affected less, because their gap is smaller to begin with.

    If your current pillow feels off, see pillow too high and pillow too low for what to check.

    Does body weight matter too?

    Yes. A heavier person sinks deeper into the same mattress and may need a lower pillow. Weight is not part of the Pillowise calculation, so the provider checks how your head and neck sit on the pillow and adjusts if needed.

    What if I don't know how firm my mattress is?

    Choose medium. We use medium for memory foam mattresses and hotel beds as well.

    What does the evidence say?

    The soft-means-lower, firm-means-higher pattern is mechanical reasoning about how bodies sink. We are not citing a study that tests mattress firmness on its own. Treat it as a rule of thumb, not a measured rule. For general guidance see what is the right pillow height and our post on choosing a pillow by sleep position and mattress.

    How does Pillowise take firmness into account?

    A fitting uses three measurements (shoulder width, neck circumference and neck height) plus your sleeping position and mattress firmness (soft, medium or firm). The Pillowise algorithm then picks one of 7 sizes. Two people with very different bodies can end up with the same size, because five factors are combined. The system indicates the right size for about 95% of people. If you want to see the measurements yourself, start with the pillow height calculator.

    You then get 7 to 10 days to adjust. After that, the pillow can be exchanged or returned within 30 days of purchase under our comfort guarantee.

    Find a provider near you

    Pillowise is sold through chiropractors, physical therapists and licensed massage therapists. The measurement is free at every provider. Find a provider near you and book a free measurement.

    Providers: to offer fitted pillows in your practice, see Pillowise for chiropractors, PTs and LMTs.

    Thijs van der Hilst, physiotherapist
    Co-founder of Pillowise